We, the leaders of the Christian Churches in the Holy Land,
are alarmed by recent developments on the ground, and are once more now
urgently demanding that the Government of Israel revoke without further
delay its decision to build a mosque on State land right in front of the
Shrine of the Annunciation in Nazareth. This Government project
contradicts the original plan made by the Arab Mayor of Nazareth, Tawfiq
Zayad to beautify the city in preparation for the year 2000. That plan
designated the same State-owned land for a public square, a pleasant
place of meeting for the city’s Christian and Muslim inhabitants, and
for the gathering of the pilgrims, facilitating their access to the
Shrine. It is this plan that we are demanding the Government to respect
and to implement.
We are surprised and distressed to see that promises and
assurances given us by Government representatives have not been
honoured, and that the requests, appeals and protests of the Christian
Churches in the Holy Land and throughout the world have been treated
with virtual contempt.
The mosque the Government approves to build is not welcome
to the Muslim religious and national authorities themselves, either in
the Holy Land or elsewhere in the world. The Government approves and
encourages the building of an unneeded mosque right in front of one of
the holiest Shrines of Christendom - to which access is already all too
difficult and uncertain - is an ill-advised plan of certain Israeli
political circles, who are making use of a marginal group of Muslims in
order to sow division between Christians and Muslims in Israel, and
among Muslims themselves. We specifically recall that leading
authorities in the Muslim world have warned against this, even as they
have expressed their criticism of this project, and of its divisive
intent and effect, and their solidarity with us.
We know for certain that a great majority of our Jewish friends, in
Israel and elsewhere, are also firmly opposed to this incomprehensible
Government decision.
It is evident that we wholeheartedly support every just
expectation of Muslims in Israel to see their right to religious freedom
fully respected. We know that there are dozens of ruined, or
semi-ruined, mosques and Muslim cemeteries in Israel that Muslim
movements and associations seek to restore, and we suggest that the
Government, before initiating an unnecessary new mosque right in front
of the Shrine of the Annunciation, permit first of all Israeli Muslims
to restore their damaged religious heritage, and to take control
directly - of the Muslim religious property now in Government hands.
We know that our Jewish friends would be deeply concerned
about the destructive effects that the Government decision for Nazareth
could have on the fruits of decades of hard work to build up and expand
the Jewish-Christian dialogue. We are therefore particularly confident
in appealing for support of Jewish religious leaders and Jewish
organizations, in Israel and world-wide.
We feel obliged to observe that, if the Israeli authorities
abuse their governmental powers to manipulate people’s religious
sentiments, to divide the population, to create conflict, to foment
intolerant fundamentalism, then they cannot credibly claim that they can
be trusted to respect any religion’s Holy Places in their
jurisdiction, whether in Nazareth or elsewhere. Indeed, we recall that
UN General Assembly Resolution 181 (II) of 29 November 1947 foresaw
international guarantees for all Holy Places throughout the Holy Land.
As the present case proves, such guarantees may now be more necessary
than ever.
Finally, we renew our appeal with a greater sense of urgency
than ever, to the Government of Israel to revoke a decision that may
have incalculable consequences on many levels, and we are asking all
Christians and Muslims throughout the world to join us in this effort,
and to do so now.
Patriarch Irenios I: Greek Orthodox Patriarchate
Patriarch Michel Sabbah: Latin Patriarchate
Patriarch Torkom II: Armenian Apostolic Orthodox Patriarchate
Father Giovanni Battistelli: Custody of the Holy Land
Anba Abraham: Coptic Orthodox Patriarchate
Bishop Swerios Malki Mourad: Syrian Orthodox Patriarchate
Abba Cuostos: Ethiopian Orthodox Patriarchate
BishopPaul Nabil Sayyah: Maronite Patriarchal Exarchate
Bishop Riah Abu Al-Assal: Episcopal Church of Jerusalem & the Middle
East
Bishop Mounib Younan: Lutheran Evangelical Church
Archimandrite Mtanious Haddad: Greek Catholic Patriarchal Exarchate
Bishop André Dikran Bedoghlyan: Armenian Catholic Patriarchal
Exarchate
Fr. Elias Tabban: Syrian Catholic Patriarchate